The Overthinking Workbook
Eight kinds of overthinking, one at a time. Read a little, write about a moment of your own, and Conscious Living AI writes back on what you wrote.
An ordinary moment
In the car on the way home we are back in the meeting. We said "I think we can manage" and a colleague raised an eyebrow. By the time we park, we have run it nine times, each with a better answer. By Thursday it is still running.
How it can sound
- I should have said something else.
- Why did I say that?
- They must have noticed.
What could be behind it
Going back over a moment can feel like the only way to understand it, or to make sure it never happens again. It can also be the mind looking for a fault in us, which gives the loop its sting. Several patterns in the library could sit behind it, and which one fits depends on what the replay keeps landing on.
Patterns in the Psychology Library that sit near it
- Rumination and worryStrong researchGoing over the past and what it says about us, or ahead to what could go wrong, in a loop that does not end in a plan.
- Hindsight biasStrong researchOnce we know how it turned out, it looks as if it was easy to see coming, so we blame ourselves for missing it.
- ShameGood researchA painful sense that we ourselves are flawed, as opposed to having done one wrong thing, with an urge to hide.
- Social anxietyStrong researchA strong fear of being judged in social settings, with a mind that rehearses and reviews each exchange.
One replay, written down
Pick one moment you went back over this week. A small one is fine.
- The moment, as it happened
- Where the replay keeps stopping
- What going over it gives me
An ordinary moment
The dentist appointment is in nine days. We have already pictured the bad news, the bill and how we will tell our family. The night before, a different worry takes its place, and by the time the dentist says it is fine, we are on to the car.
How it can sound
- What if it goes wrong?
- I had better be ready for everything.
- I will relax once this is over.
What could be behind it
Rehearsing a bad outcome feels like control. If we have pictured it, it cannot catch us off guard. The library describes worry as a way to stay with thoughts and away from feelings, which can calm us for a moment and keep the habit going. Some rehearsal ends in a plan with a first step. Much of it is only more rehearsal.
Patterns in the Psychology Library that sit near it
- Generalized anxietyStrong researchWorry about many everyday matters on most days for months, moving from topic to topic, with tension and poor sleep.
- CatastrophizingStrong researchJumping from a setback to the worst outcome, and treating it as likely and as unbearable.
- HypervigilanceGood researchA mind kept on watch for danger, scanning people and places and slow to settle.
- Need for cognitive closureGood researchA strong wish for a firm answer, which can make not knowing hard to tolerate.
One what-if, followed to the end
Pick one thing you are bracing for. It can be days or months away.
- What I am bracing for
- What I picture happening
- The first thing I would do if it did
An ordinary moment
A friend answers our long message with "ok, sounds good." We look at it for an hour. Was it cold? Did we say too much? We check whether she was online, then write a reply, delete it and write another.
How it can sound
- Why did she put it that way?
- He has not answered. What did I do?
- I need to know where we stand.
What could be behind it
Other people's minds are hard to know, and they matter to us a great deal, so a thin signal gets a lot of attention. The library lists a few patterns that could lean the reading in one direction: an expectation of rejection, a view already formed, or a relationship that has gone sour.
Patterns in the Psychology Library that sit near it
- Rejection sensitivityGood researchExpecting rejection, noticing small signs of it quickly and reacting strongly.
- Confirmation biasStrong researchOnce we hold a reading of someone, we notice what fits it more than what does not.
- Reassurance seekingGood researchAsking again and again whether things are all right, when the answer calms us only briefly.
- Negative sentiment overrideGood researchWhen a relationship has gone sour, even a neutral word from that person is heard as hostile.
One message, read twice
Pick one message, tone or silence you have been reading into.
- What they said or did, word for word
- What I decided it meant
- What I know for sure
An ordinary moment
We have three tabs open for the same laptop. Each is a few dollars apart and each has a bad review. We close them at midnight and open them at breakfast. The old one still works, and we are still shopping.
How it can sound
- One more review and I will know.
- What if the other one was better?
- I will decide when I am sure.
What could be behind it
A choice usually costs something, so each option carries a loss we would rather not have. A wish to get it right makes the weighing longer. And choices we skip can come back as a regret, which the library notes tends to weigh more over the long run than regret about something done.
Patterns in the Psychology Library that sit near it
- PerfectionismGood researchVery high standards with harsh judgment of ourselves, so a choice or a piece of work never feels finished.
- AmbivalenceGood researchStrong, opposed wants toward the same choice, so every option carries something we do not want to lose.
- Regret of inactionGood researchRegret about a chance not taken, which studies suggest tends to weigh more over the long run than regret about something done.
One choice, laid out
Pick one choice you keep turning over. A small one works as well as a large one.
- The choice in front of me
- What each option would cost me
- What I am waiting to be sure of
An ordinary moment
It is 2:10 a.m. We were tired at ten. Now we are working out how many hours remain, which makes us more awake, and the email we forgot to answer has grown into a sign that we are failing at work.
How it can sound
- I have to be up in five hours.
- I should have answered that email.
- Why does this feel so big now?
What could be behind it
At night there is little to hold the mind, and a body that stays alert could make every worry feel urgent. The library puts the body's stress response and the mind's loops side by side, and a large review found worry and rumination go with poorer sleep. It cannot say which causes which.
Patterns in the Psychology Library that sit near it
- Hyperarousal and hypoarousalGood researchToo much activation (tense, alert, unable to settle) or too little (flat, foggy), as states of the body and mind.
- Stress response and allostatic loadGood researchThe wear that builds when the body's stress response is triggered too often or fails to switch off.
- Rumination and worryStrong researchGoing over the past and what it says about us, or ahead to what could go wrong, in a loop that does not end in a plan.
One night, written down in daylight
Write this one during the day, about a recent night.
- What my mind went to in bed
- How big it felt at that hour
- How it looks now, in daylight
An ordinary moment
It has been five months. We have deleted the photos. In the grocery store a stranger laughs the way he did, and for the rest of the evening we are composing something we will never send.
How it can sound
- I wonder what they are doing now.
- I could just look once.
- It should have gone differently.
What could be behind it
A close bond leaves a lot of mental traces, and a loss takes time to settle. In the library, attachment, longing and ordinary grief each appear as possible parts of the picture. Studies on ex-partners suggest that checking up on them keeps the feeling going, though most of this research is on students and on what people tell researchers.
Patterns in the Psychology Library that sit near it
- Grief (complicated, disenfranchised, anticipatory)Good researchThe response to a loss, including a loss other people do not count, such as an ex or a job.
- Anxious-preoccupied attachmentStrong researchA strong wish for closeness together with a steady doubt that others will stay.
- LimerenceLittle researchAn involuntary, intense longing for one person, with intrusive thoughts and a fear of rejection.
One person, one moment
Pick the last time this person came into your thoughts.
- What brought them to mind
- Where my thoughts went from there
- What I miss
An ordinary moment
We said the wrong name at the party. Two people laughed kindly. In the car we are sure the whole room thought we were careless. Then we remember a friend's promotion and decide the pattern is clear.
How it can sound
- Everyone saw that.
- Other people are further along than I am.
- I always do this.
What could be behind it
We are at the center of our own attention, which makes us sure we are at the center of everyone else's. The library places that alongside comparison with others, a fear of being found out, and a harsh inner critic. Some of these have strong research behind them. Others are mostly ideas from therapy.
Patterns in the Psychology Library that sit near it
- Social comparisonStrong researchJudging our own abilities and standing by looking at other people.
- Impostor phenomenonGood researchA lasting belief that our success is undeserved, with a fear of being found out.
- Spotlight effectGood researchOverestimating how much other people notice our looks, slips and behavior.
- Harsh superego (inner critic)Used in therapy, little researchA conscience that has turned cruel and punishes the whole person, where a fair one would address the act.
One ruling, looked at
Pick one recent moment that turned into a ruling on you.
- What happened
- What I decided it says about me
- Who saw it, and what they did
An ordinary moment
A friend cancels the trip we planned for months. By the evening we can list four reasons it is understandable, two ways we could have prevented it and a theory about her schedule. Asked how we feel, we say "fine."
How it can sound
- There are three reasons this makes sense.
- It is not worth getting upset about.
- I am fine, I just keep thinking about it.
What could be behind it
Analyzing can keep a feeling at arm's length, and that may be what the analysis is for, but it is not always. In one follow-up study of people with personality or mood disorders, those who intellectualized more were functioning better, so thinking instead of feeling is not avoidance by default. The library describes this as a defense and as a difficulty putting feelings into words, and some of it as a wish not to stay with what is unpleasant. This kind has the thinnest research of the eight, and the library says so.
Patterns in the Psychology Library that sit near it
- IntellectualizationUsed in therapy, little researchHandling an emotional situation by analyzing and explaining it, which can steady a person and may keep the feeling at a distance.
- Experiential avoidanceGood researchUnwillingness to stay with unpleasant thoughts, feelings or memories, and efforts to escape or control them.
- AlexithymiaStrong researchA steady difficulty in naming our own feelings and telling them from bodily sensations.
One explanation, and what is under it
Pick something that hurt recently and that you can explain well.
- What happened
- My explanation for it
- What I notice in my body when the explaining stops
It gives no advice, and it is not therapy or diagnosis. A pattern named here is one that could explain a moment, and no more.