The masters

The masters, checked against their own words.

Lines from the masters travel fast and lose their sources on the way. For each one here we went back to the poem, the talk or the book, and we say plainly when a famous line isn’t theirs.

6 mastersBy Andrew FayadEvery source named

In short

  • Every line on these pages has a source we could open: a poem number, a chapter, or a talk with its place and date.
  • Some masters reach us mostly through translation and rewriting. Their pages check the famous lines against the source.
  • Others were recorded as they spoke, or wrote it down themselves. Their pages give their own words, with where they said them.
  • Where we found nothing, we say no source found. That is a weaker claim than calling a line fake, so we keep the two apart.

The masters

  1. Rumi1207 to 1273 · KonyaPersian poet and Sufi teacher. Much of the English Rumi on our feeds was written in the last fifty years.Famous lines, checked
  2. Lao TzuTradition says 6th century BCE · ChinaThe Tao Te Ching, eighty-one short chapters, and the lines that were added to it in English.Famous lines, checked
  3. J. Krishnamurti1895 to 1986 · India and the worldRaised to be a world teacher, he dissolved the order built for him and spent more than fifty years asking people not to follow anyone, him included.In his own words
  4. Osho1931 to 1990 · India and OregonThousands of recorded talks on meditation and watching the mind, and a commune whose leaders were convicted of serious crimes.In his own words
  5. Gurdjieffc. 1866 to 1949 · Armenia, Russia, FranceTaught that we go through life asleep. The enneagram symbol came through him. The nine personality types came later, from others.In his own words
  6. Ramana Maharshi1879 to 1950 · TiruvannamalaiLeft home at sixteen for the hill of Arunachala and gave one question for a lifetime: Who am I?In his own words

Beside the research

Most of this site is research: the Psychology Library and the field guides, each study read for what it shows and what it doesn’t. Psychology measures what it can across many people. The masters each looked at one mind, their own, for a lifetime, and some of what they reported is now being studied.

We don’t treat either side as the last word. Where the two meet, the page says so, and says how strong the research is, including when it is thin.

How we check

A line goes on a page only when we have read it in the source: a scholar’s translation for the poets, the transcript or the book for the teachers who were recorded. We quote whole sentences, never a piece cut out of one, and we name the translator or the talk.

Where a teacher reaches us through a pupil’s notes, as much of Gurdjieff does, we name the pupil. Where we couldn’t open a source ourselves, we say that too.

A question to carry

Which line have I been living by without knowing whose it is?

Questions

Why are some famous quotes marked “no source found”?

Because we looked and couldn’t find a poem, chapter, talk or book they come from. That doesn’t prove the master never said anything like it. It means nobody sharing the line has shown where it’s from, and we couldn’t either.

Are these pages religious?

They are about people, and some of those people were religious. Each page says what that person taught, where it was said, and what came after. Where a teaching belongs to a religion, as Rumi’s belongs to Islam, we say so rather than leave it out.

Why these masters?

They are the ones we keep coming back to in our own reading, and the ones most quoted on the feeds we read. More will follow, checked the same way.

Can I send a source you missed?

Yes, please. If you have the poem number, the chapter or the talk for a line we marked no source found, send it through the About page and we’ll check it and change the page.

Next