The masters · 04

Osho, read in his own talks.

He spoke for hours almost every day for decades, and nearly all of his books are transcripts of those talks. His commune in Oregon ended in crimes by its leaders. We give both: what he taught, in his words, and what happened.

9 min readBy Andrew FayadEach line traced to its talkEvery source named

In short

  • His one practice: watching. Thoughts, feelings and moods pass, and the one watching them is left.
  • His commune’s leaders poisoned 751 people in Oregon in 1984. He was never charged with it, and what he knew has never been settled.
  • The research on his Dynamic Meditation is small and weak, and we say so.
  • Of five popular “Osho quotes” we checked, three are in his talks, two of them cut down, and for two we found no source.

Who Osho was

He was born Chandra Mohan Jain in 1931 in Kuchwada, a village in Madhya Pradesh. He studied philosophy and taught it, at Jabalpur University from 1958, then left the post in 1966 to lecture across India as Acharya Rajneesh, acharya meaning teacher. From 1971 he was Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh. He dropped “Bhagwan” at the end of 1988 and was known as Osho in the last year of his life.

In 1974 he settled in Pune, where thousands of followers from the West, called sannyasins, came to his talks, meditations and therapy groups. In 1981 he moved to the United States, and his followers built a city, Rajneeshpuram, on a ranch in the high desert of central Oregon.

The commune ended in crimes. In 1984 commune members led by Ma Anand Sheela deliberately contaminated restaurant salad bars in The Dalles, Oregon, and 751 people fell ill. Sheela and others later pleaded guilty. Osho was never charged over the poisoning. He blamed Sheela publicly in 1985, and whether he knew of the plot has never been settled. That November he pleaded guilty, under a plea agreement, to two immigration charges, paid $400,000 in fines and costs, and left the country.

He returned to Pune in 1987 and died there on 19 January 1990, aged 58. Nearly all of his books, hundreds of them, are transcripts of his talks.

What he kept coming back to

Watching

The practice he came back to most was witnessing: watching thoughts and feelings pass the way we watch trees or people outside. He called it the one discipline he gave.

“Witnessing is the key of my sannyas, the master key. I don't give you any other discipline, because giving you any discipline will not help.”

The Wild Geese and the Water, talk 6, 16 February 1981, Pune

Awareness, wider than concentration

Concentration narrows attention to one thing and shuts the rest out. He described meditation as the opposite movement.

“Meditation is not concentration. Meditation is simple awareness -- widening of the mind, widening of consciousness -- expansion, not narrowing.”

Come Follow To You, Vol. 3, talk 6, 16 December 1975, Pune

Zorba the Buddha

He wanted the earthly and the spiritual in one person: Zorba, the life-loving hero of Kazantzakis’s novel, and the Buddha.

“I am trying to create a great synthesis: the synthesis between Zorba the Greek and Gautam the Buddha, the synthesis between materialism and spiritualism. I am trying to create a spiritual materialism.”

The Secret of Secrets, Vol. 1, talk 10, 20 August 1978, Pune

Laughter belongs

He held that a sense of humor belongs inside a religious life, and he joked often in his talks.

“Dancing, singing, laughing -- of these three, laughter is the most simple, the most natural and the most spontaneous phenomenon. You don't want to learn, you don't need to learn - it is a natural gift.”

Come, Come, Yet Again Come, talk 10, 5 November 1980, Pune

Belief is borrowed

Belief, in his account, is handed to us by parents, priests and the culture around us. What counts is what we find out for ourselves.

“People will inquire, and when they find, they will trust. Belief is borrowed; trust is one's own experience.”

The Secret of Secrets, Vol. 1, talk 7, 17 August 1978, Pune

Love is freedom

A follower told him they were forcing themselves to give their partner freedom, because he had said to. He said they had heard him wrong.

“I have not said that if you love, then you have to give freedom. No, I have said that love is freedom. It is not a question of giving.”

Beyond Psychology, talk 25, 24 April 1986, during his world tour

Where the psychology meets it

Psychology studies something close to his witnessing under the name decentering: seeing a thought as an event passing through the mind. It is one of the skills that mindfulness-based therapies teach. That research doesn’t test his methods, and his talks aren’t where it came from.

His best-known method, Dynamic Meditation, introduced in 1970, is an hour in five stages: fast, chaotic breathing, letting emotion out, a mantra, “Hoo”, stillness, and dance. The research on it is thin. Two small trials found some benefit over three weeks, one of them with no comparison group, and a 2022 review rated the studies moderate to poor and said the findings need caution.

At the Pune ashram, therapists from the Western human potential movement ran encounter and other groups from the mid-1970s. Sociologists who studied them found the groups worked to forge new identities by breaking taboos, and to bind members to the community.

Psychologists from the University of Oregon studied Rajneeshpuram’s residents while the commune was running. Members scored high on self-esteem and low on social anxiety, and after the collapse most former residents showed few signs of distress on standard scales. Those are self-reports from people who chose to be there, and they say nothing about the crimes.

In the Psychology Library: Rumination · Expressive suppression · Self-concept clarity

Lines that aren’t his

Lines shared under his name, checked against the talks and books.

  1. “If you love a flower, don’t pick it up. Because if you pick it up it dies and it ceases to be what you love.”

    No source found
    Where it’s from
    Not in any of the 276 books of his talks we searched.
    What the source says
    Something close is in The Dhammapada, Vol. 3, talk 3, 14 August 1979: In fact, if you have really been impressed by the flower, you cannot pluck it.
    What changed
    The idea is near his. The popular version, which ends on love as appreciation, isn’t in any talk we could find.
  2. “Be, don’t try to become.”

    Reworked
    Where it’s from
    The Book of Wisdom, talk 10, 20 February 1979.
    What the source says
    All the buddhas of all the ages have been telling you a very simple fact: Be -- don't try to become.
    What changed
    Cut from the middle of his sentence. He gives it as what every buddha has said, and doesn’t claim it as his own.
  3. “Experience life in all possible ways.”

    His, as said
    Where it’s from
    The Book of Wisdom, talk 14, 24 February 1979.
    What the source says
    And experience life in all possible ways -- good-bad, bitter-sweet, dark-light, summer-winter.
    What changed
    His words. Shared versions drop the opposites he lists after them.
  4. “Creativity is the greatest rebellion in existence.”

    Reworked
    Where it’s from
    The Goose is Out, talk 9, 9 March 1981.
    What the source says
    In the past it was inevitable that the artist had to live in rebellion, because creativity is the greatest rebellion in existence.
    What changed
    The second half of his sentence, made to stand alone. The first half ties it to artists.
  5. “Courage is a love affair with the unknown.”

    No source found
    Where it’s from
    The title of a talk in From Misery to Enlightenment (1985), but not a sentence in the talk’s text.
    What the source says
    We found it only as a heading.
    What changed
    It may well be his. Nobody sharing it has shown where he said it.

Beyond the research

“The real question is not whether life exists after death. The real question is whether you are alive before death.”

The Messiah, Vol. 1, talk 9, 12 January 1987, Pune

He said it in a talk on Kahlil Gibran’s The Prophet. Unlike some of the lines above, this one is his, word for word.

How we checked

His own website, osho.com, publishes the talks, but it wouldn’t open for our checks. We read the talks in the text of the Osho e-book library, an archive copy of 276 of his books, and matched every line on this page to it, with the series, talk number and date. Wording on osho.com can differ by a word or two. Where we find a difference, we’ll follow osho.com and change this page.

The history comes from the investigators’ report on the poisoning in JAMA, news reports from 1985 and 1990, and Hugh Urban’s history of the movement, Zorba the Buddha (2015). Anyone with a source we missed can send it to us.

A question to carry

What am I watching from, right now?

Questions

Was Osho involved in the 1984 salmonella attack?

The attack was carried out by members of his commune led by Ma Anand Sheela, who later pleaded guilty. Osho was never charged with it, and he blamed Sheela publicly in 1985. One witness testified that Sheela said she had discussed the plot with him. That was never proven.

Why did Osho leave the United States?

In November 1985 he pleaded guilty, under a plea agreement, to two federal immigration charges. He received a suspended sentence, paid $400,000 in fines and costs, and agreed to leave the country and not return for five years.

What is Osho’s Dynamic Meditation?

An hour-long meditation in five stages that he introduced in 1970: fast breathing, emotional release, a mantra, stillness and dance. The little research on it is small and weak, and a 2022 review said its findings need caution.

Is “If you love a flower, don’t pick it up” by Osho?

We couldn’t find it in the 276 books of his talks we searched. He says something close in The Dhammapada, Vol. 3: that if a flower has really reached us, we can’t pluck it.

What does Zorba the Buddha mean?

It was Osho’s name for the person he hoped for: Zorba, the life-loving hero of Kazantzakis’s novel, and the Buddha, in one. He set it against both religion that rejects the world and a life with nothing inward in it.

Sources. Osho’s talks, in the text of the Osho e-book library. Archive copy. Each line is cited above by series, talk number and date.

Hugh B. Urban, Zorba the Buddha: Sex, Spirituality, and Capitalism in the Global Osho Movement (University of California Press, 2015). Chapter 1.

Török and others (1997), “A large community outbreak of salmonellosis caused by intentional contamination of restaurant salad bars”, JAMA 278(5), 389 to 395. PubMed.

Oregon Historical Society, “Rajneeshees”, Oregon Encyclopedia. Associated Press, obituary, 19 January 1990.

Malviya, Zupan and Meredith (2022), systematic review, Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice. PubMed.

Latkin (1990), “The Self-Concept of Rajneeshpuram Commune Members”, Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 29. Paper. Latkin (1993), “Coping After the Fall”, International Journal for the Psychology of Religion 3. Paper. Palmer and Bird (1992), Sociological Analysis 53. Paper.

This page is our reading of the sources above. It will change when they, or our readers, show us something we missed.

Next